Wow! I don`t know about you two! Are you sure you cats are of
this earth? Fantastic!! I said this before, but your work kind of
kicks me in the stomach and makes me say "man, I wish I was there!"
Stunning work. Not too familiar with * Mr-Frenzy 's work, but from what I know of ^hameed 's this is amazing.
From my first glance at this, I didn't really think much of it, it didn't look that great for being a space scene, and coming from hameed it was a bit of a let down. Then my 56k kicked in and I noticed the lake with the ship, I was instantly stunned by how great this truly is.
Really amazing capture on "a night sky" I really love every bit to this. The scene with the ship is perfect for this too. Small and insignificant compare to the massive sky.
Over all design portion to this of course is incredible, the aurora turned out great and the colour content in it couldn't be more perfect. The sky is well done, stars are perfect and not to grainy, but I did find a few mishaps that should be given a second look.
Right at the top near the central bright star there is a few streaks of blue and purple. An error I assume because I really can't see how they fit into this. And the planet. Sorry, but I just don't like it at all. It fits the scene well, but as far as texturing and its shadow (which looks a bit unedited) the lighting is the only thing I like about it.
But in the end I'd say you have done a great job, and sorry to bother you with my novel up there, but just had to give you the full detailed crit. Excellent job!